I own a pizza place in Gwinnett, and I still get pizza pretty much everywhere I go. At Disney, I’m the guy ordering pizza poolside. In a hurry, I’ll grab a gas station slice. I’ve been around pizza my whole life, and I still love it. There’s just something special about this one food. That includes a lot of pizza right here in Dunwoody.

So when Discover Dunwoody put out its list of 13 pizza places, I did what I always do. I asked the neighbors. I turned their list into a poll in the Dunwoody Area Restaurant Reviews group on Facebook, and neighbors in and around Dunwoody cast over 300 votes in the first two days.

Here’s what Dunwoody picked, what I order at each spot, and where to go for the kind of pizza you’re craving. Fair warning: I think all pizza is good. You won’t find me calling anybody’s favorite overrated.

The best pizza in Dunwoody, according to over 300 votes in the Dunwoody Area Restaurant Reviews group, is Piccola New York Pizza on Winters Chapel Road (31%). Novo Cucina (17%) and Vintage Pizzeria (16%) in Dunwoody Village came next, followed by Mellow Mushroom (11%) and Varuni Napoli at High Street (9%). For a thick square pie, go to East 48th Street Market.

The Poll Results

The poll went up in the Dunwoody Area Restaurant Reviews group on November 16, 2026. Here’s where it stood two days later:

  • Piccola New York Pizza: 31%
  • Novo Cucina: 17%
  • Vintage Pizzeria: 16%
  • Mellow Mushroom: 11%
  • Varuni Napoli: 9%
  • East 48th Street Market: 6%
  • Everyone else: 3% or less

Piccola winning isn’t a surprise. The last time the group really argued about this, about five years ago, Piccola won that thread too. The surprise is Novo Cucina at number two. One neighbor called it “absolutely elegant” and said the gelato beats anything outside Italy. My friend Leah Economos of EEP Events summed up the results best: “Glad to see the OGs getting a lot of votes here.”

My Picks, by Style

My place makes regular American pizza. So when I go out, I want something different. Every spot on this list does its own thing, and I order pepperoni almost everywhere. I’m pretty basic. At least it makes for a fair comparison.

New York style: Piccola New York Pizza

Piccola is on Winters Chapel Road at Peeler Road. Thin, foldable, real New York slices. My order is a large pepperoni, well done. The group agrees with me. One voter said two large pizzas ran $65, and Piccola still gets the vote in their house.

Neapolitan: Varuni Napoli and Grana

Varuni Napoli opened at High Street in August 2026. It’s thinner and crispier, with that wood-fired Neapolitan char. My order? Pepperoni. Surprise, surprise.

Grana in Ashford Lane does a similar style. Here’s my confession: at Grana I get the garlic bread every single time. It’s a Weber family favorite. Their pizza is good. The garlic bread is why I go. I even bought a Garlic Bread Mafia T-shirt at the front counter, so yes, a pizza shop owner paid for a T-shirt at somebody else’s pizza place. The poll gave Grana 2%. I’ll still be there for the garlic bread, then out on the turf field in front with my son.

Thick and square: East 48th Street Market

East 48th Street Market is part Italian market, part deli, on Jett Ferry Road. Their Momma’s Pizza is a 16-inch square, thick pie, and I get it with pepperoni. It’s a completely different pizza from Piccola, and that’s the point. You can also pick up their pizza kits and make your own at home.

East 48th Street Market Momma's Pizza, a 16-inch square pie in Dunwoody, Georgia
Momma’s Pizza at East 48th Street Market. Thick, square and totally different from a New York slice.

The Village classics: Vintage, Novo Cucina and Mellow Mushroom

All three are in Dunwoody Village on Chamblee Dunwoody Road. Vintage Pizzeria does New Jersey-style thin crust, and neighbors love it for a slice and a salad at lunch. Novo Cucina is the Village’s sit-down Italian spot, the one where pizza can turn into a whole night. Mellow Mushroom is the easy pick when everybody in the car wants something different.

The most affordable pizza in Dunwoody: Milano Pizza & Subs

Milano’s is in the Georgetown shopping center on Chamblee Dunwoody Road, and it’s been there for decades. If you’re feeding a team after practice, this is the call. With its pickup specials, it’s the most affordable pizza in Dunwoody.

What the Group Says I Missed

The list was Dunwoody only, but neighbors added favorites just outside town: Mister O1 at City Springs, Hearth Pizza Tavern and Sunnyside Pizzeria in Sandy Springs, Unkie’s near Clairmont Road, and the hot honey pepperoni at Pizza by Yandy. That sounds like a Top End ATL pizza post. Stay tuned.

Mister O1 star-shaped pizza at City Springs near Dunwoody, Georgia
Mister O1’s star-shaped pie at City Springs. The Weber crew approves.

Vote in the Poll (and Join the Groups)

The poll is still open. Go vote in the Dunwoody Area Restaurant Reviews group, and tell us what you order. You have to be a member to see it, so join while you’re there. It’s free, and it’s the best real-time source for what locals are actually eating.

For everything else happening in town, join the Dunwoody Area Community Forum too.

Hungry for more than pizza? Here’s my guide to Dunwoody restaurants, and Discover Dunwoody’s full list of pizza places.

And if good pizza is part of why you’re thinking about moving to Dunwoody, I’m around. I’m a local REALTOR® and I’ve lived here since 2010. We can even talk pizza if you’d like. Call or text me at 404-502-8683, or grab a time to talk.

Featured photo courtesy of Piccola New York Pizza.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pizza in Dunwoody?

Piccola New York Pizza won a November 2026 poll in the Dunwoody Area Restaurant Reviews group with 31% of more than 300 votes. Novo Cucina came in second at 17%, and Vintage Pizzeria was third at 16%.

Where can I get New York style pizza in Dunwoody?

Piccola New York Pizza on Winters Chapel Road at Peeler Road is the go-to for thin, foldable New York slices. Vintage Pizzeria in Dunwoody Village does a similar New Jersey-style thin crust.

Where is the most affordable pizza in Dunwoody?

Milano Pizza & Subs in the Georgetown shopping center on Chamblee Dunwoody Road is the most affordable pizza in Dunwoody. Its pickup specials make it an easy call for big groups and teams.

Is there Neapolitan pizza in Dunwoody?

Yes. Varuni Napoli at High Street and Grana in Ashford Lane both make wood-fired Neapolitan pizza. Grana is also known for its garlic bread.

Matt Weber, Dunwoody REALTOR®

Meet Matt

Most agents know the market. I know the neighborhood.

I've lived in Dunwoody North since 2010. I host the What's Up Dunwoody podcast, make Top End ATL videos, and help families buy and sell here as a REALTOR® with Real Broker, LLC.